Showing posts with label wandering ascetics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label wandering ascetics. Show all posts

Wednesday, 12 March 2014

Buddhism among the Pueblo Indians, USA

Maya, Ashley Wells, Dhr. Seven, Amber Larson, Wisdom Quarterly; Hendon M. Harris
Eastern Shoshone tribal member Willie LeClair, 72, took his quest to the Vatican for a festival that included Italian Catholic priests and Tibetan Buddhist monks (BuffaloPost.net).
 
In response to Rain Dance (Wisdom Quarterly ceremony) Hendon Harris (author of the article “Were the Anasazi people Buddhists?”) writes in:
  
QUESTION: How can anyone deny the pre-Columbian connection between Vedic Buddhism and the culture and religious beliefs and practices of the ancient Puebloan peopleof the Four Corners as well as tribal people all across North America? Google: "Mandalas Mantras Manjis and Monuments." You prove your point, but first allow us to quibble.

Native dancers at Ohkay Owingeh, NM (wiki)
ANSWER: First of all, Hendon, what is "Vedic Buddhism"? The Buddha's Teaching or Dharma is post-Vedic. In past lives the Bodhisattva (Buddha-to-be) had been reborn a Brahmin, an expert memorizing and reciting the Vedas (the ancient Indus Valley Civilization and Indian "Knowledge Books" written by the ancient seers and sages). Brahmanism became Hinduism (the Vedic Dharma or Teachings of the Vedas), and Hinduism co-opted Buddhism trying to rein it in saying "Lord" Buddha were just another avatar, an earthly "incarnation" of Hinduism's Lord Vishnu like Lord Rama and Lord Krishna, subsuming the Enlightened One with the trinity of Hindu gods Brahma, Vishnu, and Shiva.
 
The Buddha (happySUN/flickr.com)
Buddhism is not a continuation of the Vedas and does not follow from it. The Vedas are beautiful and very advanced spiritual knowledge, but they are fraught with assumptions the wandering ascetic Siddhartha overcame by his great enlightenment (maha bodhi), his realization of the ultimate truth. When he realized it, he did not proclaim the Vedas. He proclaimed something very different -- with many superficial similarities but a different goal and many new insights not recorded in those very ancient and updated texts. For one, the central theme of these texts is that of a "soul" (atman) separated in a universe which is an illusion (maya) in the mind of Brahma trying to get back to Brahman (the reality behind the illusion). The Buddha realized that that soul is impersonal, not-self (anatman), and was thereby able to transcend all this. How many Vedic scholars can see, penetrate, or appreciate the Buddha's main insight? It is this crucial insight that distinguishes Buddhism's power to lead to authentic-enlightenment and actual final-liberation. But we're quibbling; there are, as we said, many superficial similarities (karma, dhyana, dukkha, samsara, dharma, yatra, ashtanga, piti, and so on), but the Buddha clarified what these really were from his direct knowledge not his study of the Vedas.

Leaving palace to become a shramana
What was the Shramana Movement? (Sanskrit श्रमण, Pali samaṇa, English root of shaman) was a non-Vedic Indian religious movement of wandering-ascetics rather than temple-priests parallel to but separate from the historical Vedic religion. The shramaṇa tradition gave rise to Buddhism (Alexander P. Svarghese, India: History, Religion, Vision and Contribution to the World, 2008, pp. 259-60), yoga (Geoffrey Samuel, The Origins of Yoga and Tantra, Cambridge University Press, 2008), Jainism, and some later nāstika schools of Hinduism such as Cārvāka and Ājīvika, and also popular concepts in all major Indian religions such as saṃsāra (the cycle of rebirth and death) and moksha (liberation from that cycle).

Native American pueblo or village in Taos, New Mexico (wiki)
 
Buddha cave (laka-mankong/flickr)
The Buddha rejected the authority of the Vedas and the Brahmins (brahmanas), the temple-priest-caste scholars engaged in empty rituals. The Buddha was a teacher among the wandering ascetics (shramanas). 

What "enlightenment" (bodhi) and liberation (moksha) are in Hinduism -- at the time of the Buddha as today -- is not the same as what the Buddha found. Buddhism defines enlightenment as fully penetrating the Four Noble Truths, which leads to glimpsing nirvana. And nirvana (even though the same word came to be used by different traditions all over India) is not rebirth with Brahma, melting into Brahman, or a separate self merging with a great collective self. These are all beautiful ideas, wonderful "spiritual" experiences but not what the Buddha taught was the ultimate liberation from ALL suffering. And even though Mahayana Buddhism was greatly influenced by these Hindu ideas, the Vedas, tantra, and other Brahminical teachings, the Vedas should not be confounded with the Buddha Dharma. Perhaps, Hendon, you were referring to the Vedic Sanskrit of early Mahayana Buddhist texts in Gandhara/Afghanistan, Greece, and China (Buddhist Hybrid Sanskrit)?

Native American Buddhism
Laguna Pueblo Indians (wiki)
Now who were the Native Americans, those nations destroyed by marauding bands of European invaders and settlers in what is now America? Even prior to Columbus this area, now the USA, was FULL of people. They were displaced and killed (in what could only be described as a genocide, but we can't describe it that way because European Americans might get offended the way Turks can't stand that Armenians use the word).

It is excellent, Hendon, excellent that you have seen the clear connections between ancient Buddhists and Native Americans in key components of spirituality -- mandalas, mantras, manjis, and more! Anasazi/Hopi traditions are so similar to Tibetan Vajrayana Buddhism and general shramanic/shamanic movement themes that it cannot be a coincidence.

Mandalas, Mantras, Manjis, Medicine Men (Shields-Circles), Monuments (Carved in Stone), Buffalo Horns, and Yamantaka
Hendon Harris (chinesediscoveramerica.com)
 
In [a] recent reading on ancient religious symbols and deities in Buddhism, I have been puzzled by the North American Bison horn configuration on the top of Yamantaka’s (Vajrabhairava) head. 
 
Horn configurations on the heads of different animals have a distinct pattern that tie those horns back to a specific species. This is why I have been puzzled as to why the horns on the head of Tibetan Buddhism’s favorite deity Vajrabhairava (Yamantaka) are the horn set of an animal indigenous to our continent -- the North American Bison. More

Saturday, 21 December 2013

Winter solstice: Ascetic Rituals (sutra)

Ashley Wells, Amber Larson, Dhr. Seven, Wisdom Quarterly, "Ascetics Discourse" (Jaṭila Sutta, from the collection of "Inspired Utterances" based on Ven. Thanissaro translation (Udana 1.9)
Himalayas (Raimond Klavins/artmif.lv/artmif/flickr.com)
  
Non-Buddhist ascetics have many rituals
Thus have I heard. Once the Blessed One was staying near Gayā at Gayā Head. 

At that time many wandering ascetics -- on the cold winter nights when the Brahmins honor the dearly departed [Note 1] when the snow was falling in Gayā -- jumped into and out of the frigid water [a kind of Vedic "baptism"].

They poured [clean water over themselves] and performed the fire sacrifice ritual [to burn away bad karma with the thought,] "This will result in our purification" [2].
  
Himalayan yogi (jmmnewaov2)
The Blessed One saw these many ascetics -- on the cold winter nights... -- jumping in and out of the frigid water... [with the thought,] "This will result in our purification."

Then realizing the significance, the Blessed One exclaimed: "Not by ritual water is one cleansed, even though many are bathing here. Whoever has gained truth and virtue, that person is cleansed, that person is a (true) Brahmin [3]."
 
(VP) Hayden Panettiere and the Ukrainian Revolution Dec. 6, 2013
 
FOOTNOTES: 1. The interval "Between-the-Eights" refers to India's cold season -- the "Eights" being the waning half-moon days, each falling on the eighth day of the waning cycle. This happens after three of the full moons in the cold season, which are the dates for Brahminical ceremonies to transfer merit to the (grateful) dead. The period between the first and last of these dates, or the "Between-the-Eights" interval, in northern India is regarded as the coldest part of the year. (See AN 3.34).
2. The Buddha taught that "clinging to mere rites and rituals" (silabata paramasa) with the expectation that they themselves could lead one to enlightenment or purification of view or purification of virtue is a wrong view overcome at the first stage of enlightenment, stream entry. If, for example, bathing in holy rivers such as the Ganges resulted in purity, the Buddha explains, all of the beings living there, such as fish and turtles, would be stainless, blameless, and karmically perfect.
3. The latter half of this verse is identical with the latter half of Dhp 393.

Friday, 11 October 2013

Comedy: "Festival Supreme" (sutra)

Ashley Wells, Amber Larson, Wisdom Quarterly; Jack Black (FestivalSupreme.com); Nyanaponika Thera, The Life of Sariputta (edited by Dhr. Seven); PiffTheMagicDragon.com
(FestivalSupreme.com with Tenacious D, Sarah Silverman, Bob Odenkirk...)
 
Mr. Show with Bob and David (Cross)
Tenacious D, the Greatest Band in the World, is proud to present "Festival Supreme." This is the first of its kind one-day comedy-and-music festival set to take place on Saturday, October 19 on the Santa Monica Pier in beautiful Southern California. The incredible lineup includes 25 of the best comedians around. A dream many years in the making, Jack Black and Kyle Gass are the curators of this spectacular set of comedy rock stars who will take over the pier for one special night. We’ve been trying to put this thing together for years, explains Tenacious D. It is the comedy and music event of the century, so we call it Festival Supreme! It will shake the heavens and bring this tinsel town to its knees…in a good way.
 


How Sariputra and Moggallana became ascetics
Nyanaponika Thera (trans.), The Life of Sariputta (edited by Dhr. Seven, Wisdom Quarterly)
Maha Moggallana and Sariputra, the Buddha's two chief male disciples (dhammawheel.com)
  
Sariputra, foremost in wisdom
The story begins at two Brahmin villages in India called Upatissa and Kolita, which lay not far from the royal mountain-ringed city of Rajagaha
 
Before the Buddha appeared in the world a Brahmin lady named Sari, living in the village of Upatissa, conceived.

[According to the Cunda Sutta (in the Satipatthana Samyutta) and its Commentary, the name of Sariputra's birthplace was Nalaka, or Nalagama, which may be an alternative name. It was probably quite close to the more famous Nalanda. Sariputta's father was a Brahmin named Vaganta. (Commentary to Dhammapada, v. 75).]
 
On the same day, in the village of Kolita, another Brahmin lady named Moggalli also conceived. The two families were closely connected, friends for seven generations. From the first day of their pregnancy the families gave due care to the mothers-to-be, and after ten [lunar] months both women gave birth to boys on the same day.


Later on the celebratory name-giving day, the child of Sari received the name Upatissa, as he was a son of the foremost family of the village. For the same reason Moggalli's son was named Kolita. When the boys grew up they were well educated, acquiring mastery of all the arts and sciences of the day. Each of them had a large following ("500") of Brahmin youths. Whenever they went to the river or park for sport and recreation, Upatissa used to go with a large number of palanquins, and Kolita with a large number of carriages.

Ancient Comedy Music Festival
"India" was once a vast empire.
Now at Rajagaha there was an annual event called the Hilltop Festival [which is still held in modern Rajgir]. Seats were arranged for both youths and they sat together to witness the celebrations. When there was occasion for laughter, they laughed. When the spectacles were exciting, they were excited. And they paid fees for extra shows. 

In this way they enjoyed the festival for a second day, but on the third day their understanding was awakened and they could no longer laugh or get excited, nor did they feel inclined to pay for extra shows as they had done on the first two days. 
 
Each of them had the same thought: "What is there to look at here? Before these people have reached 100 years, they will all have come to death. What we ought to do is to seek for a teaching [dharma] of liberation [from samsara, the round of rebirth and disappointment]."

It was with such thoughts in mind that they took their seats at the festival. Then Kolita said to Upatissa: "How is this, dear Upatissa, that you are not as happy and joyous as you were on the other days? You seem now to be in a discontented mood. What is on your mind?"

"Dear Kolita, to look at these things here is of no benefit at all. It is utterly worthless! I ought to seek a teaching of liberation for myself. That, Kolita, is what I was thinking seated here. But you, Kolita, seem to be discontented, too."  Kolita replied: "Just as you have explained, I also feel."

When he knew that his friend had the same inclinations, Upatissa said: "That was a good thought of ours! But for those who seek a teaching of liberation there is only one thing to do: leave home and become ascetics. But under whom shall we live the ascetic life?"

Seeking a Teacher
The Brahmin wanderers meet the Buddha
At that time, there lived in Rajagaha an ascetic of the sect of wanderers (paribbajaka) called Sañjaya, who had a great following of pupils. Deciding to get ordination under him, Upatissa and Kolita went to him, each with his own following of many Brahmin youths. All of them received ordination from Sañjaya. And from the time of their ordination under him, Sañjaya's reputation and support increased abundantly.

Within a short time the two friends learned Sañjaya's entire doctrine (dharma) and asked him: "Master, does your doctrine go only so far, or is there something beyond?"
 
Sañjaya replied: "Only so far does it go. You now know it all."
 
Hearing this, they thought to themselves: "If that is the case, it is useless to continue the ascetic life under this teacher. We have gone forth from home to seek a teaching of liberation. Under Sañjaya we cannot find it. But India is vast! If we wander through villages, towns, and cities, we shall certainly find a master who can show us the teaching of liberation." 

After that, whenever they heard that there were wise wandering ascetics or Brahmins at this or that place, they went and discussed with them. But there was none who was able to answer their questions, yet they were able to reply to anyone who questioned them. Having traveled through the whole of [the portion of] India they turned back, and arriving at their old place they agreed between them that he who should attain to deathlessness [enlightenment, liberation from samsara] first should quickly inform the other.
 
The Buddha, who was younger than Sariputra and Maha Moggallana, is depicted here on alms round in ancient India, which enjoyed a wonderful dana system of hospitality (WQ)
 
It was a pact born of the deep friendship between the two. Some time after they had made that agreement, the Buddha, [at that time referred to as] the Blessed One, came to Rajagaha. For it was when he had delivered the "Fire Sermon" at Gaya Peak that the Buddha remembered his promise, given before his enlightenment to King Bimbisara: He had promised the king that he would come to Rajagaha again when he had attained his goal.

The Buddha, a wandering ascetic (shraman)
So in stages the Blessed One journeyed from Gaya to Rajagaha, and having received from King Bimbisara the Bamboo Grove Monastery (Veluvana, just outside the main entrance to Rajagaha) he resided there.
 
Among the 61 arhats (enlightened disciples) whom the Buddha had sent forth (as missionaries) to proclaim to the world the virtues of the Triple Gem, there was the "Elder" (Thera) Assaji, who belonged to the original group of five ascetics, the Buddha's erstwhile companions before his enlightenment, who afterwards became his first monastic disciples.

Assaji returned to Rajagaha from his missionary wanderings. One morning, as he was going for alms in the city, Upatissa saw him. Upatissa was on his way to the monastery of his school of wandering ascetics. But struck by Assaji's serene and dignified appearance, Upatissa thought: "Never before have I seen such a ascetic! He must be an arhat or at the very least on the way to arhatship. 

"I should approach him and ask, 'Under whom have you been ordained? Who is your teacher, and what teaching do you profess?'" But then he thought: "It is not the proper time for putting questions to this venerable, as he is going for alms through the streets. I had better follow behind him, after the manner of supplicants." And he did so. 
 
Buddha, Kabul, National Museum (Ninara)
Then, when the elder had gathered his alms food and Upatissa saw him going to another place intending to sit down and eat his meal, he prepared for him his own ascetic's seat which he carried with him and offered it to the elder. 
 
Elder Assaji took his meal, after which Upatissa served him water from his own water-container, and in that way performed towards Assaji the duties of an Indian pupil to a teacher. After they had exchanged courteous greetings, Upatissa said: "Serene are your features, friend. Pure and bright is your complexion. Friend, under whom have you gone forth as an ascetic? Who is your teacher, and what teaching do you profess?"

Assaji replied: "There is, O friend, the Great Recluse, the son of the Sakyas [a family clan far to the northwest], who has gone forth from the Sakya clan. Under that Blessed One I have gone forth. That Blessed One is my teacher, and it is his Dharma that I profess."

"What does the venerable one's master teach, what does he proclaim?"
 
Enlightenment
The heart of wisdom: anatta (impersonal)
Questioned thus, Assaji thought to himself: "These wandering ascetics are opposed to the Buddha's dispensation. But I shall show him how profound this dispensation is." So he said: "I am but new to the training, friend. It is not long since I went forth from home, and I came but recently to this teaching and discipline. I cannot explain the Dharma in detail to you."
 
The wanderer replied: "I am called Upatissa [the future Sariputra], friend. Please tell me according to your ability, be it much or little. It will be my task to penetrate its meaning by way of a hundred or a thousand methods." He added: 

"Be it little or much that you can tell, 
The meaning only, please proclaim to me!
To know the meaning is my sole desire;
Of no avail to me are many words."
 
In response, Elder Assaji uttered this stanza:

"Of all those things that arise from a cause,
The Tathagata [Buddha] the cause thereof has told;
And how they cease to be, that too he tells,
This is the doctrine of the Great Recluse."
 
[The exact ancient Pali words recorded are: "Ye dhamma hetuppabhava tesam hetum tathagato aha, tesañca yo nirodho evamvadi mahasamano 'ti." This verse was later to become one of the best-known and most widely spread Buddhist stanzas, standing as a reminder of Sariputra's first contact with the Dharma and also as a worthy memorial to Assaji, his great arahat teacher. Spoken at a time when the principle of karmic causality was not accorded the prominence it enjoys today in philosophical thought, its impact on the minds of early Buddhists must have been revolutionary.] 

EDITORIAL NOTE: How could these few lines ever lead anyone to stream entry? Ven. Pa Auk Sayadaw explained to us that implicit in this brief statement of the Buddha's teaching are the Four Noble Truths, the Dharma in a nutshell. Sariputra (Upatissa) was of such brightness, quickness, sharpness, and clear perception that he immediately cut through to the heart of the teaching. For he, like Maha Moggallana (Kolita) and the Buddha's two chief female disciples, Khema Theri and Uppalavanna Theri, had been cultivating and waiting for a buddha to arise so as to be his chief disciples for aeons. First truth: there is this. Second truth: it has a cause. Third truth: there is liberation (from suffering). Fourth truth: that, too, has a cause -- namely one to be developed with the Noble Eightfold Path.
 
Upon hearing the first two lines, Upatissa became established in the path of stream-entry [the first of the various stages of enlightenment], and hearing the ending of the last two lines he listened in the fruition of a stream-winner. More

So remember, kids, you too can become disenchanted and set off on a quest for truth and liberation. It all starts with Festival Supreme! Ask your parents for money.